Why I Won't Be A Surgeon

A Choice I Never Expected To Make

On February 2016, I decided that I wanted to be a surgeon.

After just watching my first surgery at St Thomas’ hospital, I even marked the date with a cheeky Instagram post.

I had finally figured out what I’d be doing for the rest of my life.

The idea of being a surgeon always appealed to me — Preparation, Perfectionism and Artistry. The perfect combination.

By the spring of 2017, I figured I was going down the route of surgery. I even took a year out to study further modules on the subject of anatomy and surgical sciences.

The work was fun, I met some great mentors, and for the first time in forever, I was self-motivated.

Life was good.

The Introduction of Doubt

During one of my lectures on the science behind surgery, the lecturer kicked off by serving some unexpected advice: 

‘If I were you, I’d take your degree and leave’.

The whole room went silent.

We knew, of course, the context for this remark — the idea of leaving medicine was no stranger to us.

In fact, it’s the elephant in the room that many of us condition ourselves to ignore.

For me, however, at that moment, every doubt I’d buried away about a career in surgery began to resurface, clouding my mind with doubt and uncertainty.

But what bothered me most? — If I had felt so sure about my future, how could a single comment rattle me so much that I’d be questioning my decision for months to come?

An Unexpected Twist

In my final year of medical school, I founded a society that aimed to help medical and dental students find ‘their speciality’.

Our mission struck a chord with numerous students — with so many specialities to choose from, we were all experiencing decision paralysis.

The speakers we were lucky enough to bring down presented us with a realistic expectation of what the training pathways were like and an honest evaluation of the pros and cons, serving their best attempt at impartial guidance.

Despite being convinced that I had thought everything through, each speaker made me progressively contemplate how inadequately I’d performed my field research — There was so much new information.

It began to dawn on me that I’d never given my options any serious, uninterrupted thought.

The irony was, despite the intention being to help others, this platform was about to completely transform my own career trajectory.

A Game of Values

If it was a matter of deciding one medical speciality, I had my answer.

The problem was, at the time, I had given some serious consideration to the idea of an entirely different career: Entrepreneurship in Healthcare.

It wasn’t until the later stages of medical school that I rediscovered a secret I’d buried away for some years — I love to create things.

Despite only a year or so of dabbling in entrepreneurship, I was hooked.

It demanded a steep learning curve that required a ‘jack of all trades’ skillset, something I strongly identified with.

The big question now was — Do I remain a doctor, pursue entrepreneurship or find a middle ground?

Around this time, I stumbled across a blog post by a growth marketer I followed at the time — Julian Shapiro.

It was dedicated to a small exercise he had used to decide what best to spend his time on, something that centred around his values.

I decided to play, too.

Here are a few of the values I came up with:

  • Accruing knowledge — I wanted a learning curve; preferably something which didn’t pressure me to ‘subspecialise’ without my desire to.

  • Adventure — Building novel and memorable experiences in my career and free time.

  • Exercising talent — Being in a position to utilise my skills and talents; having an element of creative freedom.

  • Human connection — Outside as much as inside of work. I also wanted to spend time with friends and family, a lot of it.

I considered each of my top career options against these values, and the outcome really opened my eyes to what I needed to be doing.

The Outcome

After much deliberation, I came to a carefully considered cocktail of endeavours I could pursue side by side:

1. I’d be a General Practitioner (GP) with special interests in Paediatrics and Medical Education.
2. I’d create written and audio-visual content for teaching material and beneficial content for like-minded individuals.
3. If and when I’d find myself passionate enough to double-down on a business idea, I’d dedicate some years to entrepreneurship.

Becoming a GP would mean that I’d have several days off a week to pursue other ventures whilst maintaining a breadth of clinical knowledge across numerous specialities.

This would prove beneficial for both medical education and keeping a pulse on entrepreneurial possibilities.

Creating content would not only compliment my aim to become a medical educator but also provide transferable skills that would come in handy if creating a startup.

Most of all, this balance of pursuits would still provide me with the flexibility to travel, spend time with loved ones and take out the necessary time to reassess my career trajectories.

Would it have been possible to juggle all this whilst remaining a surgeon?

Most definitely, but with all my side-interests I’m not so sure that I’d become the best surgeon I could be.

And I didn’t want that.


I don’t expect you to be in the exact position I was in, but I’d like to think my journey can provide anyone with a few key points to reflect upon.

Here are a few takeaways:

  1. Don’t ignore the feeling that you might be going in the wrong direction.
    It’s there for a reason. If you don’t question it now, you can’t expect the answers either. Leave it till later and you’ll have more to lose.

  2. No matter how deeply involved you are, it’s ok to change direction.
    Not everyone ends up going down the path that’s best for them, particularly on their first attempt. The only way to identify if that includes you is to constantly reflect on what you’re doing and where you’re going. If it doesn’t align with your core values, it’s not too late to make some changes.

  3. It’s ok to sacrifice something you love.
    I’d love to believe that we can have everything we want in life, but the reality is that sometimes you have to give something up in order to gain something better.

I gave up being a surgeon.

And I’d like to think I did it for the right reasons.

I’m thinking of telling the full story in the form of a Youtube video. 

If you’d like that, please let me know by commenting below, replying to this email or hitting me up on any of my socials.

If you liked this article, you might like this one too: Get Out of The Fast Lane

✏️ About the Author:

👨🏽‍⚕️Faisal is a Junior Doctor working in the NHS and the founder of YoungAcademics.

💌If you’ve been sent here by a friend, join a growing tribe of 160+ readers interested in personal growth and subscribe here (FREE). 🚀

☕️If you’re feeling generous today and would like to support his content, you can buy him a coffee.

🤝Let’s be friends!






📺Watch my latest video on Youtube below!